Below are my Wine Enthusiast reviews for April 2020. Wines are listed alphabetically by winery. Read information on how I review wines here. Read about the Wine Enthusiast rating system here. Read about how to interpret my scores here. All of these reviews are freely available on-line at the Wine Enthusiast Buying Guide. See previous Wine Enthusiast reviews re-published in this space here. Search Wine Enthusiast's on-line database here. Read instructions on how to find Washington wine reviews at Wine Enthusiast here.
Well folks, hard times are upon us, but that doesn’t mean we can't still enjoy wine. It just means having to drink a little smarter, as many are forced to tighten the purse strings. Thankfully, Washington wine is your friend in this regard, offering an abundance of high quality wines wines that deliver well above their price point.
From the April set of reviews from Wine Enthusiast, I’ve singled out here 10 wines to help us all get through these tough times. They are all exceedingly well priced for the quality that’s in the bottle. As lovers of Washington wine know, there are many more like them (see the full list of April reviews below). See a list of
promotions that Washington wineries are doing here.
Without further ado!
Chateau Ste. Michelle 2018 Dry Riesling Columbia Valley $9,
91 points,
Best Buy
What more can I say about the
Ste Michelle Dry Riesling that I haven’t said before? This is quite simply the best wine value in the United States. Period. Better still, you can find it at your grocery store while you’re stocking up (not hoarding people!) on toilet paper. 2018 is one of the best vintages ever. Only seeing the 2017 or 2016? Don't worry. They are supremely delicious too.
Involuntary Commitment 2018 Columbia Valley $20 92 points
Well, well, well. Since the release of the first vintage, the Involuntary Commitment wines, a side project from the folks at
Andrew Will, have hit way above their weight class. The 2018 vintage is something else altogether, however, drinking easily like a wine two times or more times the price. You just don’t ever see this kind of quality at this price in Washington for Bordeaux-style wines. Stock up. This early release wine also augurs well for the 2018 vintage in Washington.
Grosgrain 2018 Petit Grosgrain Red Blend Walla Walla Valley $24,
93 points,
Editor’s Choice
I did a triple take when I saw the price of this wine from
Grosgrain. Then I double checked it on-line. A blend of Mourvèdre, Syrah, and Grenache from Walla Walla Valley at this quality and price? Unheard of. Far from a big bruiser, this wine is all about elegance and sophistication. But it is the balance and length that truly separates it.
Animale 2016 Stainless Steel Aged Cabernet Franc Yakima Valley $26,
93 points,
Editor’s Choice
This wine from
Animale is one of the most exciting wines I’ve ever had from Washington – wholly fermented in stainless steel. It shows a level of purity and detail that is completely mesmerizing. Honestly, it’s changed the way that I think about Cabernet Franc in Washington, and it’s only $26.
L'Ecole No. 41 2018 Semillon Columbia Valley $15 91 points,
Editor’s Choice
The
L’Ecole Semillon is one of Washington’s best kept secrets. Year after year after year, it delivers. The 2018 vintage is one of the winery’s best yet, with full fruit flavors of fig and kiwi. Better still, it’s a wine that only improves with some time in the cellar, perfect for hunkering down for the days ahead.
L'Ecole No. 41 2017 Merlot Columbia Valley $25,
92 points,
Editor’s Choice
This bottle from L’Ecole encapsulates everything that I love about Washington Merlot. Broad feeling and fruitful, but with more than ample acidity and firm tannic structure backing it up. It’s Washington Merlot at its best. I kept coming back to this wine over an almost two week period, and it seemed to be near immortal, perfect for now or stashing away.
Syncline 2018 Subduction Columbia Valley $25,
91 points,
Editor’s Choice
This wine from Gorge producer
Syncline is a consistent standout, and the 2018 vintage continues that trend. A blend of Syrah, Grenache, Mourvèdre, Carignan, and Cinsault, it has arresting aromas of blue fruit, strawberry and herb that lead to bright, focused fruit flavors. If you’re looking for a wine that puts a premium on purity and elegance, look no further.
Seven Hills Winery 2017 Merlot Walla Walla Valley $25,
92 points,
Editor's Choice
This wine was the inspiration for the
2020 Washington Merlot Challenge. 2017 is looking to be a stellar vintage for Merlot. This wine is full of aromas and flavors of raspberry, red currant, baking spice and milk chocolate, showing a sense of deftness. It delivers a whole lot of quality for this price.
Ott & Hunter 2017 Double Bluff Whidbey Island Landmark Series Columbia Valley $23 90 points
This Whidbey Island producer, renamed
Ott & Hunter from Ott & Murphy, has been quietly chugging along, making high quality, well priced wines for some time. This blend of Grenache, Mourvèdre, Counoise, and Cinsault is full of peppery spices and light, juicy flavors that show a lot of elegance.
Reininger 2017 Mr. Owl’s Red Blend Walla Walla Valley $20 91 points
Cabernet Sauvignon from
Reininger makes up over half of this wine, with the balance Merlot, Syrah and Petit Verdot. The aromas are exuberant, with notes of orange peel, cherry, and fresh flower. A full feeling palate follows, brightened by tart acidity. Give it a decant if drinking in the near term. High quality Walla Walla wine for $20? Yes please.
Colter's Creek 2017 Estate Bottled Syrah Lewis-Clark Valley (ID) $20 91 points
Bonus wine! What’s this Idaho interloper doing on this Washington wine list? Delivering some kick ass value from this cross border appellation, that’s what!
Colter’s Creek is making increasingly compelling wines from this nascent appellation (see other reviews below). This offering is full of fruit forward aromas and flavors of blueberry pie and orange rind with a sumptuous feel.
Below is a full list of April Wine Enthusiast reviews. Enjoy!
* * *
Animale 2016 Stainless Steel Aged Cabernet Franc Yakima Valley $26 93 points
This is the only example of this variety I am aware of from the state all aged in stainless steel. The aromas offer uncommon purity, depth and detail, with notes of strawberry, raspberry, herb, whole orange and whiffs of cranberry. The palate is layered and exquisitely balanced and has a long, orange- and cranberry-filled finish. It’s spectacular—an accomplishment.
Editor's Choice
Animale 2016 Reserve Cabernet Franc Yakima Valley $28 92 points
Bright, achingly pure aromas of raspberry, strawberry and cranberry are followed by palate-coating fruit flavors that show more of the same. A long, blood orange- and cranberry-filled finish follows. It’s a complete delight—one of the best offerings of this variety coming out of the state.
Editor's Choice
Array 2015 Dijon Clone Chardonnay Yakima Valley $32 91 points
This winery focuses exclusively on Chardonnay. Aromas of corn on the cob, peach, lees and spice are followed by full-bodied, textured stone fruit flavors that stretch out on the clean finish. It’s a compelling example of the variety.
Array 2015 Nina’s Reserve Chardonnay Yakima Valley $36 88 points
The aromas offer notes of lees, candied red apple and spice. It’s enjoyable, but the lees flavors get pretty intense and somewhat overwhelm the wine at times.
Ashan 2017 Celilo Vineyard Chardonnay Columbia Gorge $40 92 points
Fruit for this wine comes from 1973 plantings. Barrel fermented and aged sur lie for nine months with weekly bâtonnage. Aromas of toast and wet stone are out front, needing some time to fully settle in. The palate is full feeling, creamy but still deft, bringing an impressive sense of acidity that carries the flavors on the extremely long finish. Give it some time to settle in. Best after 2022.
Ashan 2017 Cold Creek Vineyard Chardonnay Columbia Valley $40 90 points
The aromas offer notes of clarified butter, lanolin, toast, flower and pear. Full-bodied, creamy-feeling peach flavors follow, capped off by a (quite) warm finish. It’s a lovely contrast to the winery’s Celilo Vineyard offering, showing the many facets of the variety.
Avennia 2017 Justine Yakima Valley $40 93 points
Grenache (61%) is in the lead on this wine, followed by Mourvèdre (23%) and Syrah. Alluring aromas of raspberry, blueberry, thistle, herb, smoked meat and black pepper are followed by lush, achingly pure red and blue fruit flavors, accented by a lovely sense of spicing. It’s deft but pure. Smoked meat and black pepper notes linger on the extremely long finish. The balance throughout is impressive—a complete stunner. Best from 2023 to 2030, with good life beyond that.
Editor's Choice
Avennia 2017 Gravura Columbia Valley $40 93 points
Cabernet Sauvignon (47%) and Merlot (42%) make up the heart of this wine, with Cabernet Franc providing its soul. The aromas impress, with notes of bay leaf, thyme, graphite, dark coffee, raspberry and spice. The palate is classically styled and exquisitely balanced, bringing a sense of sophistication and detail, with plentiful cherry and herb accents. There’s lovely sense of complexity. Firm, slightly green tannins back it all up. Just a baby now, it wants some time in the bottle to grow up. Best from 2024 to 2032.
Cellar Selection
Brian Carter 2018 Oriana White Wine Blend White Blend Columbia Valley $25 91 points
A unique blend of Viognier (49%), Roussanne (41%) and Riesling. The aromas are fruit-forward, with notes of ripe peach, flower and melon. The palate drinks off-dry, rounded in feel but still, light, with citrus, stone fruit and floral flavors. It has a pleasing yum factor.
Brian Carter 2013 One Klipsun Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon Red Mountain $85 90 pointsBarrel aromas are at the fore at present, with notes of vanilla, cocoa and wood spice, along with generous amounts of dried herbs, graphite and a light medicinal streak. The palate brings lighter feeling black tea flavors and cherry, painting a bit around the edges. It seems slightly more evolved than one might expect for its age.
Brian Carter 2015 Trentenaire Columbia Valley $50 90 points
This is always one of the more interesting wines in the state, a Petit Verdot (55%) dominant blend, rounded out with Cabernet Franc (19%), Cabernet Sauvignon (10%), Merlot (10%) and Malbec. I am not aware of another like it. Aromas of roasted coffee bean and green herb are out front, followed by notes of dark chocolate, spice, herb and cherry. Barrel flavors are forward at present, but there’s plenty behind them to pull it off. Petit Verdot’s unique acid and tannin structure carry it. It should have a long life in front of it
Brian Carter 2016 Corrida Spanish-style Red Blend Columbia Valley $34 89 points
This is a blend of 66% Tempranillo, 21% Graciano, 8% Garnacha and 5% Cabernet Sauvignon—something few producers in the state are exploring. The aromas bring a fair amount of reduction out of the gate. Behind that are notes of roasted coffee bean, cassis and licorice. Fresh tobacco, coffee and dark chocolate flavors follow. Coffee notes linger on the finish. It’s equal parts promise and delivery.
Brian Carter 2015 Tuttoroso Red Wine Blend Red Blend Yakima Valley $34 89 points
Sangiovese (68%) is at the heart of this wine, surrounded by Cabernet Sauvignon (17%) and Syrah. Aromas of dried tobacco, tar, raspberry, tire rubber, coffee and cherry are followed by creamy-feeling fruit flavors. The reduction on the aromas is a bit distracting.
Brian Carter 2015 Paul Thomas Bandol-style Columbia Valley $50 88 points
This wine is dedicated to one of winemaker Brian Carter’s friends and mentors. In this blend of Mourvèdre (61%), Grenache (25%), Cinsault (8%) and Syrah, sweet spice, dried herb, flower and licorice aromas make up an interesting mix. Full, lightly creamy flavors follow.
Brian Carter 2015 Solesce Columbia Valley $65 88 points
Coming from the warmest vintage this state has seen to date, this wine is 60% Cabernet Sauvignon, 16% Merlot, 11% Petit Verdot, 8% Cabernet Franc and 5% Malbec. The aromas pop, with notes of tobacco, tire rubber, coffee and cherry, reduced out the gate. Lip-smacking, slightly dried out seeming flavors follow. It’s an odd mix and hard to tell where it’s going at present.
Carl's Pond 2013 Merlot Yakima Valley $16 89 points
With this 100% varietal, vanilla and baking spice aromas are in front of raspberry and cherry notes. The cranberry and cherry flavors are reserved in style, showing a pretty sense of balance. It’s an intriguing wine, made in a style more common in the state in the ’90s than in recent years.
Carl's Pond 2014 Rattlesnake Ruby Red Blend Rattlesnake Hills $16 88 points
This wine is 58% Cabernet Sauvignon, 34% Merlot and 8% Syrah, aged 26 months in a mixture of French and American oak. The aromas provide intrigue, with notes of cinnamon, pipe tobacco, vanilla, sweet barrel spice and savory herb. The palate’s cherry flavors are reserved in style, bringing a sense of freshness, with plentiful herb accents. Put it on the dinner table to see it at its best.
Carl's Pond 2014 Syrah Rattlesnake Hills $16 87 points
Aromas of vanilla, cocoa, mesquite, cola and cherry are followed by lighter-styled fruit and barrel flavors that trail toward the finish. A light medicinal note runs throughout.
Catman 2017 Sangiovese Columbia Valley (OR) $42 90 points
Pale in color, the wine has aromas offering light notes of red fruit and spice. Light, elegant, focused fruit flavors follow, bringing a vibrant sense of acidity, despite its high alcohol level. It doesn’t entirely stand up on its own but will do well on the dinner table. Pair it with roasted pork loin.
Catman 2017 Malbec Columbia Valley (OR) $32 89 points
The aromas jump out of the glass, with notes of bright raspberry, fresh red currant, orange rind, a sprinkling of savory herb and a whiff of mesquite. The palate is flavorful and juicy, chock-full of red fruit flavors, with blood orange notes on the finish. It displays a pleasing sense of elegance—an intriguing offering of this variety.
Catman 2017 Quatrèsbon Red Blend Columbia Valley (OR) $32 86 points
This wine is a unique blend of Cabernet Sauvignon, Merlot, Malbec and Zinfandel. The aromas start out quite reduced, bringing strong notes of burnt tire rubber in front of red fruit. The palate is fuller in feel, with notes of fresh green herbs and red fruit.
Chateau Ste. Michelle 2018 Dry Riesling Columbia Valley $9 91 points
The aromas are perfumed, with appealing notes of flower, lime leaf, orange peel and white peach. Bone-dry, mouthwatering stone fruit flavors follow, showing spot-on balance and a lingering finish. It’s a complete delight.
Best Buy
Cinder 2018 Dry Viognier Snake River Valley (ID) $23 89 points
Viognier is the variety that led winemaker Melanie Krause to move back to Idaho to make wine, and this wine shows the promise. The aromas draw you into the glass with notes of flower, herb, peach and pear. Medium-bodied, well-balanced flavors follow. It shows a lovely sense of acidity for the variety.
Cinder 2018 Dry Gewürztraminer Snake River Valley (ID) $30 88 points
Somewhat subdued aromas of flower are followed by pear and ginger notes. The palate is dry, crisp and medium bodied in feel, with tart acidity providing the frame. It’s equal parts intrigue and delivery and should shine at the dinner table. Try it with roasted chicken basted in an herb butter with citrus and sage.
Cinder 2016 Reserve Tempranillo Snake River Valley (ID) $80 88 points
Aromas of cocoa, vanilla, fresh tobacco, graphite and black cherry are followed by rounded, palate-coating dark-fruit flavors with a tart finish. A firm coil of tannins connects it together.
Cinder 2017 Syrah Snake River Valley (ID) $30 87 points
Vanilla extract, sweet baking spice, dried tobacco and plum aromas are followed by tangerine, plum and dried tobacco flavors that thin out toward the finish. The wood seems to get in the way at times.
Cinder 2018 Dry Rosé Snake River Valley (ID) $23 85 points
Darker in color than many offerings coming from the Northwest, this wine shows reduction out of the gate, making the aromas of cherry and watermelon hard to tease out. Medium-bodied cherry flavors follow, tapering toward the finish.
Colter's Creek 2017 Estate Skookumchuck Syrah Lewis-Clark Valley (ID) $25 91 points
Arresting aromas of fresh herbs, blueberry, smoked meat, tangerine, wet gravel and black pepper are followed by silky smooth, mesmerizing flavors, bringing an outrageous sense of texture. Orange peel notes linger on the finish. Delicious stuff.
Colter's Creek 2017 Estate Bottled Syrah Lewis-Clark Valley (ID) $20 91 points
Vibrant aromas of blueberry pie, dried orange rind, cranberry and boysenberry lead to full-bodied, richly flavorful blue and purple fruit flavors. The sumptuous feel only adds to the appeal. It’s fruit-forward and unabashedly delicious.
Colter's Creek 2017 Rocinante Red Blend Lewis-Clark Valley (ID) $36 90 points
A blend of Mourvèdre, Graciano and Malbec, this wine is pale in color, reminiscent of a Pinot Noir. The aromas show notes of fresh herbs, cherry, cranberry, white pepper and Satsuma orange. Light, peppery flavors follow, accented by bright acidity. It shows a lot of delicacy and should shine at the dinner table. Pair it with grilled lamb and chimichurri.
Editor's Choice
Colter's Creek 2016 Arrow Rim G-S-M Idaho $20 88 points
Subdued aromas of raspberry compote, cranberry, barrel spice, dill and herbs lead to soft fruit and barrel flavors that generally play well off each other but at times tussle.
Colter's Creek 2017 Estate Cabernet Franc Lewis-Clark Valley (ID) $28 88 points
Aromas of fresh and dried tobacco are at the fore along with green, savory herbs and green pepper. The palate is light but full in feel, chock-full of savory flavors. It’s a lovely but pretty green offering of the variety.
Devona 2017 Chardonnay Washington $44 92 points
Winemaker John Abbott (formerly of Abeja) has always been one of the state’s most skilled Chardonnay makers, and we see that here. The aromas draw you into the glass, with notes of clarified butter, spice and almond, showing a sense of subtlety. The peach and nectarine flavors are full in feel, coating the palate from end to end, brightened by lively acidity. It lingers on the finish. Superb stuff.
Editor's Choice
Devona 2015 Bacchus Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon Columbia Valley $70 91 points
Devona is a new project from winemaker John Abbott, previously at Abeja, where he showed his mastery of Cabernet Sauvignon. Coming from 1972 plantings at this vineyard, the aromas start out subtle, with notes of graphite, vanilla, raspberry cordial and spice. Well-balanced, creamy-feeling coffee and cherry flavors follow, showing a sense of sophistication, particularly for such a warm vintage.
Devona 2016 Merlot Columbia Valley $50 90 points
Fruit for this wine comes from Bacchus Vineyard. Aromas of Red Vines candy, cherry cordial and spice are out front. Well-balanced red fruit flavors follow, leading to a warm finish. A firm sense of structure backs it up. There’s no mistaking the variety.
Drink Washington State 2017 Welcome to Washington State Reserve Chardonnay Columbia Valley $29 89 points
The aromas intrigue, with notes of corn on the cob and wet stone along with whiffs of caramel and spice. The palate is medium-plus bodied, extending on the finish.
Drink Washington State 2016 Escape to Walla Walla Red Blend Walla Walla Valley $29 87 points
The aromas are unusual, with notes of dried stem, fresh tobacco, black currant, medicine cabinet and orange peel, not seeming entirely integrated. The palate brings a mixture of full-feeling green herb and tart red fruit flavors. It comes off as quite green.
Eternal 2016 Eternal Discovery Discovery Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon Horse Heaven Hills $59 90 points
This vineyard is making a name for itself with Cabernet. Black licorice, dark raspberry, Satsuma orange and herb aromas are out front, followed by graphite and a sprinkling of spice. A mouthful of rich red and dark fruit flavors follow. Firm but fine-grained tannins provide support. It provides a lot of intrigue and delivery.
Eternal 2018 Eternal Sunshine Viognier Columbia Valley $34 89 points
All of the fruit for this wine comes from Gamache Vineyard. The aromas offer notes of Jolly Rancher, flower and honey-drizzled peach, showing the intensity of a dessert wine. The palate is rich in flavor, showing a ripe style, tapering toward the warm finish.
Eternal 2017 Eternal Restraint Syrah Walla Walla Valley $49 88 points
Fruit for this wine hails from Bogin Vineyard and comes in at an almost unheard of alcohol level for a current day red from the state. The aromas offer unusual notes of orange peel, evergreen, smoked meat, green herb and dark fruit. As the name would imply, the palate is reserved in style, with a strong sense of acidity. Orange peel notes persist on the finish. It doesn’t all completely work, seeming quite green, but it’s certainly interesting.
Fujishin 2018 Gewurztraminer Snake River Valley (ID) $NA 88 points
Sweet herb aromas are out front, trailed by notes of whole lime and a whiff of ale. Dry, broad-feeling citrus flavors follow. Spice flavors linger on the warm finish. It brings appeal.
Gorman 2018 Big Sissy Chardonnay Columbia Valley $35 91 points
For a producer typically known for its brawny wines, this one has that but also a lovely sense of subtlety, with notes of chalk, cardamom and plentiful barrel spice. The peach flavors bring nuance with their creamy, full feel. A warm, fruit-filled finish caps it off.
Gramercy 2016 Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon Columbia Valley $95 93 points
This wine is a blend of Cabernet from Bacchus Vineyard in the White Bluffs and Phinny Hill in the Horse Heaven Hills. Forward aromas of dark coffee bean, milk chocolate, dried and fresh herbs, barrel spice and dark cherry are followed by initially light, well-balanced fruit flavors that ramp up in depth and intensity over time. A tight coil of tannins holds it all together. This one will require some patience but has all the stuffing to go the distance and then some. Best after 2025 with a long life beyond that.
Cellar Selection
Gramercy 2016 John Lewis Syrah Walla Walla Valley $85 93 points
As time has gone on, this wine has gotten more and more ambitious, drawing down its alcohol to the present 12.8%. With this barrel selection from Red Willow, Forgotten Hills and Les Collines vineyards, the aromas are reserved, with notes of black pepper, dried stem, herb, lavender and smoked meat. The palate is packed full of tart fruit flavors that stretch out on the finish. Quite firm tannins back it up. Most Washington wines you can pop and pour or wait a decade to enjoy. This is an exception, requiring significant time to see its best, but it is more than worth the wait. Drink after 2027, but it will have a long life beyond that, appearing near immortal.
Cellar Selection
Greenwing 2017 Cabernet Sauvignon Columbia Valley $30 91 points
This is a new Cabernet Sauvignon project from the folks at Duckhorn, doubling down on Washington to go along with their Red Mountain focused Canvasback brand. The aromas mesmerize in notes of café au lait, black currant, plum, bay leaf and spice. The palate is deft in style, full of well-balanced, creamy-feeling flavors of coffee, spice and cherry, with lightly grainy tannins backing it up. It’s a lovely mix of fruit and barrel.
Editor's Choice
Grosgrain 2018 Petit Grosgrain Red Blend Walla Walla Valley $24 93 points
Mourvèdre makes up 43% of this wine, with the rest Syrah (34%) and Grenache (23%). The aromas start out high register, with notes of herb, dried flower, peppery spice and blue fruit. The palate is simultaneously flavorful and deft, with tart acidity and a long, drawn out finish. This is extremely impressive stuff, with exquisite balance and an outrageous value to boot.
Editor's Choice
Grosgrain 2018 XL Vineyard Mourvèdre Walla Walla Valley (OR) $36 91 points
This is the first example of Mourvèdre I am aware of from this vineyard, with it also being an extreme rarity in the valley. Brooding aromas of raspberry, green herbs, thistle and spice are followed by reserved fruit, cranberry-tart fruit and savory flavors. A long finish caps it off. It needs to be accompanied by food to be fully appreciated, but it’s terrific. Pair it with grilled lamb with a cherry compote.
Editor's Choice
Grosgrain 2018 Los Rocosos Vineyard Grenache Walla Walla Valley (OR) $36 91 points
Pale in color, this young release wine was aged in neutral oak with 15% stems. The aromas offer notes of strawberry, raspberry and dried herb. The flavors are light, elegant, fresh, juicy and focused. Strawberry and smoked meat flavors linger on the finish. It’s a lovely, graceful wine, made it a style few (any?) producers in the state are exploring. It shows impressive staying power as well. Best with a slight chill.
Editor's Choice
Hat Ranch 2018 Dry Estate Grown Moscato Snake River Valley (ID) $18 90 points
Vibrant aromas of melon, flower, tangerine peel and pear lead to dry drinking flavors. It’s a one-wine charm offensive.
Hat Ranch 2016 Hat Trick Red Blend Snake River Valley (ID) $27 88 points
Aromas of red cherry, vanilla and wood spice are followed by fruit and barrel flavors on the lighter side of medium-bodied wine. Coffee notes linger on the finish. The oak gets out front at times.
Helix by Reininger 2017 Stillwater Creek Vineyard Sangiovese Columbia Valley $27 88 points
Bright, fresh aromas of raspberry, sour cherry and orange peel are at the fore. The palate brings a pleasing sense of elegance, with the tannins adding some grit. Give it some additional time in the bottle to see if they soften.
Helix by Reininger 2016 Bacchus Vineyard Merlot Columbia Valley $22 88 points
Bacchus is one of the state’s oldest vineyards, located in the White Bluffs region. The aromas bring notes of coffee and raspberry, with plentiful spice accents. The palate comes off as a bit green, dipping in the middle, with a lot of tannic structure. Coffee notes persist on the finish.
Involuntary Commitment 2018 Columbia Valley $20 92 points
This side project from the folks at Andrew Will is consistently one of the best values in the state. A blend of Cabernet Sauvignon, Cabernet Franc and Merlot, with coffee, cherry and savory herb aromas out front. The palate brings a sense of balance, intensity, depth, purity and sophistication.
J. Bookwalter 2019 Couse Creek Vineyard Rosé of Pinot Noir Walla Walla Valley $26 92 points
This wine is made in a Beaujolais Nouveau style—100% whole cluster with cool carbonic maceration, aged two weeks on skins, and released the Thursday before Thanksgiving. However, it brings a whole lot more seriousness and staying power than many of the wines that inspired it. The aromas pop, with appealing notes of strawberry, dried herbs and stem. The palate is light, fresh and juicy, fleshing out over time. It’s a complete delight, and a dynamite example of this variety to boot.
Editor's Choice
L'Ecole No. 41 2017 Ferguson Estate Vineyard Walla Walla Valley $65 92 points
Cabernet Sauvignon (60%) and Merlot (28%) comprise the majority of this wine, with Cabernet Franc (7%) and Malbec rounding it out. Aromas of dried leaf, savory herb, dark chocolate, cassis and dried thyme draw you into the glass. The palate shows a sense of polish to the classically styled cranberry and cherry flavors. Lively acidity and brawny, slightly green tannins back it all up. Oak spices linger on the finish. It has the acidity and tannin stuffing to go the distance and then some. Best after 2025 with a long life beyond that.
Cellar Selection
L'Ecole No. 41 2017 Merlot Columbia Valley $25 92 points
The baking spice, dark raspberry and anise aromas provide appeal. Broad-feeling, textured flavors follow, with cranberry-tart acidity and brawny, firm tannins backing it up. It’s an extremely impressive offering of this variety, showing its more serious side—Washington Merlot at its best. It will shine at the dinner table and will have a long life in front of it, seemingly near immortal.
Editor's Choice
L'Ecole No. 41 2017 Estate Grown Merlot-Cabernet Franc Walla Walla Valley $39 92 points
This wine is equal parts Ferguson and Seven Hills Vineyards and is similarly split between these two varieties. The aromas are locked up at present, with notes of graphite, cedar, barrel spice, coffee, dried herb, cherry, cranberry and anise coming out with coaxing. Plump, ripe fruit flavors follow, accented by vibrant acidity and enough tannic structure to go the distance. It flat out impresses. Best 2023–2033.
Cellar Selection
L'Ecole No. 41 2018 Semillon Columbia Valley $15 91 points
Generous aromas of fig, kiwi and freshly spun cotton lead to a full, flavorful palate that brings a sense of texture and richness. It stretches out on the long, warm finish.
Editor's Choice
L'Ecole No. 41 2017 Estate Grown Seven Hills Vineyard Syrah Walla Walla Valley $37 88 points
Coffee, green herbs, vanilla and blue fruit lead to full-bodied flavors, with the tannins giving a slightly tacky feel. The oak comes off prominently at present. Give it some time to (hopefully?) integrate. Best after 2022.
Laissez Faire 2018 Red Blend Snake River Valley (ID) $18 89 points
This young release red offers plum, orange peel, currant and spice aromas. A plump, flavorful, elegant palate follows. It’s a wine that makes you want to come back for more.
Mark Ryan 2018 Viognier Yakima Valley $40 93 points
The aromas bring plenty of appeal, with notes of honeysuckle, flower, whole pear, crushed rock and peach, bringing a sense of nuance. The palate is full but crisp in feel, showing a lovely sense of tension and depth, along with lively acidity. Structure, balance, depth, intensity, dexterity.
Editor's Choice
Mark Ryan 2017 Crazy Mary Mourvèdre Red Mountain $60 93 points
The aromas draw you into the glass, with notes of dark coffee, pure blue fruit, dried herb and a kiss of spice. Full-feeling, palate-coating blue fruit flavors follow, lingering on the long, smoked meat and peppery finish. It commands attention, showing a lovely sense of texture and purity.
Editor's Choice
Mark Ryan 2017 Little Sister Merlot Columbia Valley $75 93 points
Fruit from Quintessence Vineyard on Red Mountain makes up 86% of this wine, with the rest coming from the considerably cooler Red Willow in Yakima Valley. With this 100% varietal, the aromas start out brooding, with notes of Red Vines candy, dark raspberry, herb and dark chocolate. Bright, vibrant, palate-coating, textured red fruit and barrel flavors follow. It shows a lovely sense of depth and intensity but still freshness, with a lingering finish capping it off. Best after 2023.
Cellar Selection
Mark Ryan 2016 Lost Soul Red Willow Vineyard Syrah Yakima Valley $50 92 points
The aromas jump out of the glass, with notes of coffee, blue fruit, dried herb, mineral and dark chocolate. Soft, textured, palate-coating fruit flavors follow that sail on the finish. A lovely sense of acidity ups the interest. This wine could only come from one place. It’s completely captivating.
Editor's Choice
Mark Ryan 2017 The Dissident Columbia Valley $40 92 points
Cabernet Sauvignon makes up almost two-thirds of this wine and Merlot a quarter, with the rest Cabernet Franc and Petit Verdot. The aromas offer notes of dark and red raspberry, red currant, roasted coffee bean, dried herb and flower. Fruit and barrel flavors coat the palate, showing a sense of depth, with a creamy feel upping the interest.
Editor's Choice
Mark Ryan 2017 Dead Horse Cabernet Sauvignon Red Mountain $60 92 points
Quintessence, Ciel du Cheval, Klipsun and Obselisco fruit make up this wine. Aromas of vanilla, black coffee, dried herb, graphite, plum and dark cherry lead to a full, creamy-feeling, flavorful palate, intertwining fruit and barrel flavors. Coffee notes linger on the warm finish. A firm coil of slightly green tannins gives it support. Allow it some additional time in bottle. Best after 2023.
Mark Ryan 2017 Long Haul Merlot Columbia Valley $55 92 points
Though always Merlot dominant (and 84% in this vintage), this wine has not carried a varietal label in some time. A blend of Quintessence, Red Willow, Ciel du Cheval and Phinny Hill fruit, with brooding raspberry, coffee bean, cigar box, crème de cassis and herb notes out front. The palate mixes fruit and barrel, showing a lovely sense of deftness to the creamy-feeling flavors. Firm structure backs it all up, with café au lait notes lingering on the finish. It shows why this variety is so special in Washington.
Editor's Choice
Mark Ryan 2018 Olsen Vineyard Chardonnay Yakima Valley $40 90 points
There’s a lovely vibrancy to this wine’s pear, flower and peach aromas. Ripe, almost viscous-feeling flavors follow. Toast notes linger on the warm finish. It shows the variety’s richer, more unctuous side.
Mark Ryan 2017 Wild Eyed Syrah Red Mountain $50 89 points
There’s no mistaking the variety, with its aromas of pot roast sprinkled with dried herbs, blue fruit and flower showing a pleasing sense of complexity. The palate is full bodied but remains deft, with a textured feel and a firm sense to the tannins. A medicinal streak runs throughout, and it finishes quite warm.
Mercer 2017 Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon Horse Heaven Hills $25 88 points
Green herb, smoke, cherry, spice and whole lemon aromas lead to slightly tacky-feeling cherry, black currant and orange peel flavors. It comes off as quite green.
Mercer 2016 Small Lot Merlot Horse Heaven Hills $32 88 points
Aged 24 months in 40% new American oak; the aromas offer notes of vanilla, dried cherry and sweet barrel spice. Vanilla, nougat and cherry flavors follow on the palate. The oak plays a leading role.
Mercer 2017 Bros Red Blend Horse Heaven Hills $20 87 points
This wine explores the variety’s greener, more savory side, with notes of green pepper and garden herb, along with black currant and whiffs of smoke. The palate is sweet, with the tannins seeming a bit bunched up. Café au lait notes linger on the finish. It’s an easy drinker.
Mercer 2017 Reserve Heritage Red Blend Horse Heaven Hills $25 87 points
Aromas of mesquite smoke and smoked ham are out front, along with fresh black currant and barrel spice, with the palate showing more of the same. A strong medicinal note lingers on the finish.
Ott & Hunter 2016 Saratoga Whidbey Island Landmark Series Columbia Valley $35 91 points
Syrah comprises half of this wine, with the rest Mourvèdre (30%) and Grenache. With the fruit coming from Boushey, Elephant Mountain and Sugarloaf vineyards, the aromas seem a bit bunched up out of the gate, expanding to show notes of blueberry, freshly ground black pepper and spice. A full but not overweighted feeling plate follows, with abundant black pepper accents. It has a lovely sense of grace. Give it some time open to see it at its best.
Ott & Hunter 2017 Double Bluff Whidbey Island Landmark Series Columbia Valley $23 90 points
Grenache, Mourvèdre, Counoise and Cinsault all make up equal parts of this wine. It’s light in color, reminiscent of a cool climate Pinot Noir. The aromas provide notes of strawberry and cherry gummy, along with pine and peppery spice. The palate is light and juicy, extending on the finish. It’s a pretty, elegant offering.
Ott & Hunter 2015 L’Entente Red Blend Columbia Valley $43 88 points
This is a unique blend of three-quarters Syrah, 20% Petite Sirah and 5% Malbec. The aromas intrigue, with notes of smoked meat, evergreen, parsley and purple fruit. The palate is light, with a strong medicinal streak. It’s all an odd mix.
Ott & Hunter 2016 Boushey Vineyard Malbec Yakima Valley $36 88 points
The aromas intrigue, with notes of flower, orange oil, evergreen and asphalt. A medium-bodied palate follows, full of somewhat lighter orange peel flavors. Grapefruit notes linger on the finish. It’s interesting, but the fruit doesn’t seem to have fully ripened.
Ott & Hunter 2015 Sugarloaf Vineyard Grenache Rattlesnake Hills $27 88 points
Aged in neutral French oak for 32 months, aromas of cigar box, herb and ripe raspberry are followed by ripe, full-bodied cranberry and cherry flavors. It finishes warm. The aromas and flavors don’t seem to entirely sync up.
Ott & Hunter 2016 Wooly Heart of the Hill Vineyard Petite Sirah Red Mountain $45 88 points
In this 100% varietal, aromas of raspberry compote, evergreen and cherry cough drop are followed by fruit flavors on the lighter side of medium bodied. It comes up short on the finish.
Ott & Hunter 2016 Boushey Vineyard Syrah Yakima Valley $35 88 points
The aromas offer notes of overripe blueberry, blackberry and spice. Jammy, ripe but still lighter-styled flavors follow. This oft-expressive vineyard seems to get lost.
Ott & Hunter 2016 Elephant Mountain Vineyard Syrah Rattlesnake Hills $35 87 points
This wine was aged 32 months in a second-fill French oak barrel. The aromas bring notes of dark fruit, vanilla and abundant barrel spices. The palate mixes fruit and barrel, with the latter winning out.
Reininger 2017 Merlot Walla Walla Valley $30 91 points
Pepper Bridge (64%) and Seven Hills (32%) vineyards make up most of this wine, with the rest coming from XL. It starts out quite reduced. Coffee and raspberry aromas are out front, followed by notes of graphite and spice. The palate is dominated by structure right now, very tightly wound up, but there are a lot of good things poking out. Coffee and chocolate notes linger on the finish. Give it until 2024.
Cellar Selection
Reininger 2017 Mr. Owl’s Red Blend Walla Walla Valley $20 91 points
Cabernet Sauvignon comprises 56% of this wine, with the rest Merlot (19%), Syrah (19%) and Petit Verdot. The aromas are effusive, with notes of orange peel, fresh flower, cranberry and cherry. A full-feeling palate follows, with the cherry flavors brightened by tart acidity and supported by firm tannins. Coffee notes linger on the finish. The sense of structure is lovely. Best after 2024.
Reininger 2017 BDX Walla Walla Valley $30 88 points
The aromas are locked up out of the gate, with notes of wood spice, cranberry, cherry and mint. Fruit and barrel seem to tussle on the palate, with the tannins bringing a bit of astringency. Perhaps some additional time in the bottle will bring it together.
Reininger 2017 Pepper Bridge Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon Walla Walla Valley $40 88 points
This wine is 100% varietal. The aromas bring notes of fresh black currant, asphalt, smoke and barrel spice. A plush feeling, dark fruit-filled palate follows, showing a bit of astringency. Smoke notes linger on the finish.
Sawtooth 2018 Dry Classic Fly Series Riesling Snake River Valley (ID) $18 87 points
The aromas offer notes of lemon iced tea, wilted flower and peach. Dry fruit flavors follow, trailing toward the lemony, lip-smacking finish.
Sawtooth 2017 Classic Fly Series Petit Verdot Snake River Valley (ID) $35 85 points
Unusual aromas of pink grapefruit and wood spice are followed by light, citrusy flavors. The fruit doesn’t seem to have fully ripened.
Seven Hills Winery 2017 Merlot Walla Walla Valley $25 92 points
The aromas provide appeal, with notes of pure raspberry, red currant, baking spice and milk chocolate. The medium-bodied palate shows a sense of deftness to the fruit and barrel flavors. It’s a terrific example of the variety.
Editor's Choice
Sin Banderas 2017 Yakima Valley $32 91 points
Syrah makes up two-thirds of this wine, with the rest Mourvèdre. The aromas intrigue, with notes of herb, orange oil, anise, dark chocolate and cherry. A full, lightly creamy-feeling palate follows. Cranberry notes linger on the finish. It has a long life in front of it.
Sin Banderas 2018 DuBrul Vineyard Riesling Yakima Valley $24 91 points
Lighter-styled aromas of lime, cut green apple, mineral and citrus are followed by sleek, bone-dry stone fruit flavors that bring puckering acidity. The vibrant acidity keeps the interest high. Pair it with halibut accompanied by a nectarine and peach salsa.
Editor's Choice
Sin Banderas 2016 Yakima Valley $32 90 points
Syrah and Mourvèdre make up equal parts of this wine. The aromas offer notes of coffee, dark chocolate, herb, cranberry and ample barrel spicing. The palate is creamy in feel, with coffee, raspberry and cherry. Barrel spices linger on the finish. The oak plays prominently, but by and large it works. It has a long life in front of it.
Syncline 2018 Estate Grown Gamay Columbia Gorge $35 91 points
This is the first release of this variety off the winery’s estate vineyard and a rare offering from the state. The aromas provide vibrant notes of raspberry, Red Vines candy, peppery spice, red gummy and strawberry. The palate is light, tart and elegant, with the achingly pure fruit front and center. It’s flat-out delicious—required reading for anyone interested in one of the cutting edges of Washington wine.
Editor's Choice
Syncline 2018 Subduction Columbia Valley $25 91 points
Syrah makes up half of this wine, with the rest Grenache (18%) and near equal parts Mourvèdre, Carignan and Cinsault. The aromas are arresting, with notes of blue fruit, smoked meat, strawberry and dried herb, showing pleasing complexity. The palate starts out quite elegant in style, fleshing out with time, juicy, with bright, focused, pure fruit flavors. A long, fruit-filled finish caps it off. There’s a lot going on. Pair it with roasted pork loin.
Editor's Choice
Syncline 2017 Scintillation Brut Grüner Veltliner Columbia Gorge $40 90 points
This is a single-vineyard (Underwood Mountain), single-vintage, single-varietal sparkler—a unicorn in the wine world. The aromas pop, with notes of pear, citrus, biscuit, melon rind and a whiff of smoke. The palate is dry with a zip of acidity and plentiful autolytic accents. Tasty stuff.
Editor's Choice
The Guide 2018 Pinot Noir Oregon $15 90 points
Aromas of cinnamon, peppermint, spice, smoke, cherry and celery salt intrigue. The palate is light, elegant and well-balanced, fleshing out over time, with a light lick of tannins. Blood orange notes linger on the finish. It brings a lot of appeal.
Best Buy
The Guide 2017 Discovery Red Blend Columbia Valley $14 88 points
Plum, herb, blood orange and smoke aromas are followed by light, soft, medium-bodied blue fruit flavors that go down easy. It’s a straightforward quaffer.
The Guide 2017 Cabernet Sauvignon Columbia Valley $15 87 points
The aromas show notes of garden herb, orange peel, mesquite and raspberry, with the palate showing more of the same, accented by a touch of sweetness. A citrus twist flavor lingers on the finish.
Vale 2018 Chardonnay Snake River Valley (ID) $21 86 points
Aromas of burnt toast, peach and pear are followed by corn on the cob and peach flavors. It’s an odd mix.
Vizcaya 2014 Tempranillo Snake River Valley (ID) $29 89 points
Fruit for this wine comes from Windy Ridge Estate. The aromas bring notes of dried cherry, cedar, tobacco, vanilla and herb. The flavors are full in feel, backed by lively acidity. It brings a lot of intrigue.
Woodward Canyon 2017 Old Vines Cabernet Sauvignon Washington $99 92 points
As always, this wine is a blend of fruit from Champoux and Sagemoor vineyards, both first planted in the early 1970s. The aromas are reserved, with notes of blackberry, vanilla, spice and cigar box not yet ready to reveal themselves. Full, palate-coating, layered flavors follow, showing a lot of intensity. It packs a big punch, with a warm finish following. It’s all about opulence but keeps it in balance.
Woodward Canyon 2016 Estate Old Vines Cabernet Sauvignon Walla Walla Valley $69 91 points
The fruit for this wine comes from the winery’s estate vineyard, established in 1976, with a microscopic 64 cases produced. The aromas provide immediate appeal, with notes of assorted fresh and dried herbs, cassis, vanilla, green pepper and black currant. The palate brings rich toffee, vanilla and cherry flavors that add a lightly grainy feel. The oak is primary at present, needing time to integrate.
Bud break is beginning in eastern Washington. James Mantone, owner and winemaker at Syncline Winery, noted bud break in Gamay Noir, pictured here, at the winery's Steep Creek Ranch Vineyard in the Columbia Gorge appellation on March 27th. Mantone said this was about five to seven days earlier than in 2019.
